State Appellate Judicial Evaluation Committee


The committee evaluates persons whose names are submitted by the Governor for possible nomination to the California Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal, particularly the Second Appellate District. When requested by the Board of Trustees, the committee also evaluates candidates for any appellate court.

The Chairs of the State Appellate Judicial Evaluation Committee:

1989 - 1991   Hon. Richard Amerian, (ret.)
1991 - 1992   Pamela E. Dunn
1992 - 1994   Kent L. Richland 
1994 - 1995   David S. Ettinger 
1995 - 1997   Robert S. Gerstein
1997 - 2001   Marc J. Poster
2001 - 2007   Edward J. Horowitz 
2007 - 2011   Claudia N. Ribet 
2011 - 2013   Hon. Carlos Moreno, (ret.)
2013 - 2020   Benjamin G. Shatz
2020 -             Alana H. Rotter


The Chairs of the State Appellate Judicial Evaluation Committee:

1989 – 1991   Richard Amerian
1991 – 1992   Pamela E. Dunn
1992 – 1994   Kent L. Richland
1994 – 1995   David S. Ettinger
1995 – 1997   Robert S. Gerstein
1997 – 2001   Marc J. Poster
2001 – 2007   Edward J. Horowitz
2007 – 2011   Claudia N. Ribet
2011 – 2013   Hon. Carlos Moreno
2013 –            Benjamin G. Shatz
 

 

Committee Leadership 

 

Chair

Alana Rotter
Greines, Martin, Stein & Richland LLP

Vice Chair

Mary Susan Pithey
Dept of Justice/Atty Gen Ofc

 

SEE THE FULL STATE APPELLATE JUDICIAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE ROSTER
 

Los Angeles County Bar Association Logo Copyright 2026 LOS ANGELES COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION 
(213) 627-2727